Tamara Review form

TAMARA: Journal of Critical Organization Inquiry

Editor: David M. Boje
New Mexico State University
Department of Management
Box 30001/ Dept. 3DJ
Las Cruces, New Mexico 88003-8001
(505) 646-1001
Fax no. (505) 646-1372
email reviews to

Reviewer's Report to the Editor

Manuscript No.: ____

Title: _________________________________________________________________________________

Reviewer Name: _________________________

Date Sent to Reviewer_____/_____/00

Date Due From Reviewer: ______/_____/00

Recommendations:

____Accept as is

____Accept pending minor revisions

____Revise and Resubmit

____Reject

Basis for Revision:

____Needs More Focus
____Too Long (over 25 pages)
____Jargon Not Explained
____Claims Not Fulfilled
____Theoretical Contribution is Unclear
____Needs Clarity of Purpose
____Too Many Purposes
____Sloppy Composition
____Key Literatures Are Not Cited
____Analysis Not Explained
____Other ________

Basis For Rejection:

____Does Not Address TAMARA themes ________
____Would Have to Rewrite Paper From Beginning to End
____Not an Original Contribution
____Needs Conceptual Overhaul
____Not a Significant Contribution to Field
____Technically Inadequate
____Lots of Opinion, but Little Data
____No Persuasive Theory
____Support of Central Claim Not Compelling
____Other __________________________________________

Comments To The Editor:

Comments To The Authors (Please be constructive):